Means no $ for Ed
School districts are beginning negotiations with their unions based on their 2010-2011 budget numbers, which are depressing. If it’s impossible to draw blood from a turnip, just try to wring money from state legislatures for education.
The Colorado legislature is about to claw back $250 million+ from public schools for the ‘10-’11 year. It will probably take back just as much, if not more, for ‘11-’12. If school districts don’t have enough reserves, and no one does, they will be going backwards in funding for years.
Money saving tricks
Some districts are freezing salary - no COLA, no steps and levels. Others are doing furlough days. Others are charging for transportation. Others are ending all technology purchases. Others are emptying administration - no more professional development for teachers or curriculum support! Others are increasing classroom size by one, two, or three children. Last but not least, some districts are closing buildings.
No more investing in education!
Investment in education has stopped. Districts that have made progress in student achievement will probably freeze in place or will start drifting backwards. After all, if no one is in charge any more of managing the voluminous data underlying each student’s progress, how will the analytical process thrive that supports achievement?
Schools going backward in funding
The largest district in Colorado is about to cut $60 million from a $670 million budget. The district estimates it will make the same size cut in ‘11-’12, and possibly again in ‘12-’13. That means that by ‘13-’14, unless miracles happen, the district will be at a budget starting point roughly $180 million below where it is today. And yet the District is supposed to get every student to meet annual growth targets.
Colorado calculates annual growth against student peers. Proficient students are measured against proficient students, barely proficient against barely proficient, etc. So the only good news for schools is that all students in the state are in the same hole, so the lack of annual achievement growth should be relatively similar. This prediction will assure funding remains at about the same dismal level for all schools in the state.
Not enough tax dollars for education today
Colorado is almost last in state funding per student, at about $7300, even though the state has one of the highest college education levels. This “Colorado paradox” happens because educated out-of-staters like to come and live here for the mountains. The state is also reasonably affluent. But like other western states, including California, citizens prefer to keep their money in their pockets. Colorado has one of the lowest state income tax and sales tax levels in the country.
How’s that Obama money doing?
ARRA money has bailed districts out in 2010, but now everyone is headed towards a cliff. What kind of help is the Obama administration offering? Race to the Top, of course, or as some wags say, slow jog to nowhere. Really, the $4 billion will go to schools doing education Arne Duncan’s way, which means pay-for-performance and closing non-performing schools or turning them around or starting over.
What does any of that do to help districts whose schools aren’t completely in the doghouse yet (but may be after two or three years of these budget cuts)?
What would you do if you could?
And will pay-for-performance really do the trick with teachers? Schools definitely need something beyond steps and levels, but what should that look like? Do schools need a more streamlined way to move bad to mediocre teachers out? Yes. Do schools need more money for entry level teachers, so education can compete at least marginally with law and medicine for top graduates? Yes. Do schools need a way to pay off student loans to encourage teachers to work in challenging schools? Yes.
How about a little extra money for some teacher career tracking - giving teachers money for online course development, professional development of peers, etc.
Get your 30 in and retire
It’s true that some relationship needs to exist between compensation and how well kids learn, but that’s not the whole package. And frankly, in Colorado, teachers and districts are going to be so busy plowing money into their PERA pension fund, they may not get a raise for years. They are mostly going to be working for that glorious final moment when they stagger over the 30 year finish line and can get out of education altogether. Not very pretty, is it?
Tags: COLA, furlough days, growth targets, pay for performance, salary freezes, school budgets, student achievement, student growth
the future for our children now, is poor education, no activities, no clubs, no band, no sports, no hope for college. It will increase crime, drop outs, trouble. gangs. It will put us back 50 years. what a shame to allow this to happen.